The Murder of the Deaf and Dumb boy in Utah

The Murder of the Death and Dumb Boy In Utah
Harper's Weekly
February 26, 1859

We give herewith a couple of illustrations of a scene which, though a matter of history, will seem incredible to persons unacquainted with passing events in Utah.

One of the most objectionable features in the Mormon theocracy is the right which it arrogates to itself to shed blood upon ecclesiastical pretexts. Brigham Young preaches in one of his sermons, as published in the Deseret News, as follows:

“I do know that there are sins committed of such a nature that if the people did understand the doctrine of Salvation they would tremble because of their situation; and, furthermore, I know that there are transgressors, who, if they knew themselves, and the only condition upon which they can obtain forgiveness, would beg of their brethren to shed their blood, that the smoke thereof might ascend to God as an offering to appease the wrath that is kindled against them, and that the law might have its course.”

President Grant, in a sermon published in the same paper, remarks: “There are men and women among us that I would advise to go to the President immediately and ask him to appoint a Committee to attend to their case, and then let a place be selected, and let that committee shed their blood.”

A terrible instance of this fanaticism has occurred quite recently, which will greatly enlighten our readers as regards the frequent atrocities of this anomalous sect. A poor deaf and dumb boy, who was known to be a witness in a case of “Danite” assassination, which would certainly have commanded the attention of the Federal Court, has, for some time past, been the subject of general anxiety among those who expected to see the laws faithfully executed. Some time ago, one of the most respectable merchants in the Territory proclaimed in Camp Floyd that the boy would, very likely, fall a victim to the Danites. Such insolent hardihood, in the face of an organized Federal Court, supported by a formidable posse comitatus, could scarcely be credited. The prediction, however, has already been verified.

“Dummy,” as the boy was called, was the son of a poor Mormon widow. He was simple almost to idiocy. His poverty and misfortunes had enlisted the sympathies of the whole Gentile community, who delighted in giving him alms. When the contemplated assassination was whispered abroad the interest in his behalf became universal. But all at once the poor mendicant was missing from the streets. “Where had Dummy gone? Where has Dummy gone?” was the query on every side. The Mormon answer was that he had gone into the country to work. A month or more elapsed, and the poor widow became solicitous about her son.

It is well known that the maternal attachment is always strongest toward those children who are most unfortunate. Such seems especially to have been the case with Mrs. Bernard. Long since left alone in the world with only her deaf and dumb child, she had beguiled a sad widow's life in his nourishment and instruction. She could communicate intelligibly with him my signs, and to a certain extent (notwithstanding his simplicity), could awaken within him a sense of right and wrong. As it too often happens, however, in such cases, her indulgence was greater than her prudence. Supposing the poor mute could not possibly excite the apprehensions of the Prophet, she either wittingly or unwittingly permitted him to mingle with the Gentiles. This, in accordance with the Danites code, requires that his blood should be spilled as incense to God.

But who could be found so fiendish as to accomplish so foul a deed? The quotation above, from Grant's sermon, answers the question. A “committee,” consisting of Christiansen and Eph Hanks, are appointed. The sequel will show that they perpetrated a murder which, for fanaticism, Barbarity, and utter contempt for law, has no parallel in the civilized world. In obedience to the ecclesiastical dictum, Christiansen (armed with a revolver and bowie-knife) set forth on his mission of death on the 12th of November. On the same day he arrived at Eph Hanks's shanty.

His pretext for accosting Dummy was that he has stolen money. Dummy, not being able to comprehend him, produced eleven dollars in dimes and half dimes, which he has received as charity. This is not enough. Christiansen draws his revolver and threatens to shoot him. The terrified mute flies. The assassin fires four shots at him, three taking effect.

The bleeding body was then thrown on a load of wood and conveyed to an obscure canon, where the work of death was completed by cutting his throat from ear to ear, Eph Hanks assisting by holding the head.

A hole was dug, the body thrown in and covered with earth, but nothing was said about it for several weeks. The poor widow suspecting something wrong, consulted the Prophet. He at once acknowledged the murder, but assured her it was necessary for his salvation that his blood should be offered up as an atonement to God.

The Federal authorities heard of the matter, and endeavored to bring the fiend to justice,; but with a Mormon Grand Jury, sworn by the most fearful oaths to sustain Brigham, no true bill was found. Christiansen is released and frequently over his cups facetiously boasts that Dummy was the hardest fellow to kill he ever tried. It took a whole day to do it.