When Capitol National Monument was expanded in 1969, approximately 300 acres owned by Lurton and Alice Knee at Pleasant Creek became an inholding. By this time the Knees had built a house, lodge, cabins, and a small, concrete block motel on a knoll overlooking horse corrals and fenced pastures. They had maintained an irrigation canal, spring and pump water system, and had constructed a power/telephone line through Pleasant Creek Gorge to the west. The Knee’s acreage was up to approximately 300 acres, with a lease on an adjoining state section, as well (Frye, 1992).
Because of the insufficient $423,000 initial cap placed on private land acquisitions in the 1971 legislation, acquisition of the entire Sleeping Rainbow Ranch had to be delayed. Meanwhile, 140 acres of the ranch were purchased for $300,000 in the fall of 1974 (Master Deed Listing, 1993). When the acquisition ceiling was raised in 1966, the Knees realized that their chance to sell the rest of the property was at hand. They decided to sell their land to a church thereby establishing a tax-free trust fund that would provide them with steady retirement income. The chosen church would then sell the land to the National Park Service. The other key provision of any deal would be that the Knees and their children would be granted life residency to a portion of the land (Master Deed Listing, 1993).
Around 1976, the Knees approached officials at Brigham Young University in Provo, Utah, with their proposal. The university, in consultation with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, determined that it could not meet all of the Lurton Knee’s stipulations. The Knees then revised their life estate requirement, dropping their children from the provision, and turned to the more flexible Seventh Day Adventist Church (Superintendent Correspondence, 1976).
In January 1978, earnest negotiations began between the National Park Service and Lurton and Alice Knee. Sherman W. Swenson, National Park Chief of the Division of Land Acquisition, spent a day with the Knees hammering out an initial deal. The Knees agreed to sell 235 acres, so long as they could retain 25 acres as a life estate. They would also retain right-of-way for their spring and pump water system, root cellar, the power and telephone lines, and the rights to water and pasture necessary to keep three horses. Swenson reported, “It is my recommendation that we go along with their requirements. The price is okay. Our only alternative to this is condemnation, and in light of the present climate regarding our use of condemnation, I would recommend against it” (Superintendent Correspondence, 1978).
(Note: Portions of Political Context narrative drawn from Bradford J. Frye’s From Barrier to Crossroads: An Administrative History of Capitol Reef National park, Utah. 1992.
- Cultural Landscape Inventory, Pleasant Creek Settlements: Floral Ranch and Sleeping Rainbow Ranch, National Park Service